Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts

9.24.2009

9/21 - Decemberists (with Laura Viers) @ The Wellmont Theater in Montclair, NJ

Decemberists 9/21 – Wellmont Theater (Montclair, NJ)

I managed to catch The Decemberists Monday night, and like fine wines and some cheeses, it got better with age.

Having never seen the Decemberists in concert before, this was a fantastic way to get to know them live. The show was broken into two sets, plus a two-song encore that included an acoustic preview of a new song (mumbled as “January Moon” or something similar).

The First Set: complete play-through of “The Hazards of Love”, and it included guests Becky Stark (Lavender Diamond) and Shara Worden (My Brightest Diamond) as the damsel Margaret and fierce diva Queen characters. The second set was a mixed bag of old-school Decemberists songs, from Crane Wife, Castaways & Cutouts, and plenty more.

The first half marched forward like a fairly well-oiled machine. There were some sound oddities (levels were potted up late - sometimes 15 seconds late!) here and there, but the roadies scampered out to hand off guitars, change mics and generally keep the seven performers going for the hour-long epic. And it impressed, mostly – what sonic highs and lows get lost on the compressed album came across like a freight train onstage. Becky Stark’s vocals were powerful (something untrue about the album’s mastering), the numerous repetitions of the “Wanting Comes In Waves” themes seemed to bust through the Wellmont’s dome, and five of the seven players busting out sticks and drumming their way through “The Rake’s Song” was a sonic and visual peak that felt like Polyphonic Spree, circa 1873.



On a sidenote, something else that was quite personal to me: the epilogue track (“Hazards of Love 4 – The Drowned”) was never a favorite of mine, but it gained new resonance for me after seeing it onstage – the crowd that applauded the finale quickly sobered when Colin and Becky reminded everyone that their characters were to be reunited in death. No matter how much the crowd wanted to respond, the story had to finish itself. Thus is the purpose of the epilogue.

The stage play between “characters” was minimal, and I honestly expected a little more. Granted, Colin was playing his guitar, but Becky/Margaret mostly spun around onstage like she was looking to fill the repetitive phrases of the opus. Shara’s performance as the queen was flapper-esque and full of diva quality – subtle nuances of her relationships with other characters shined through… all while she danced and strutted in giant heels.

In general though, what comes across as an oddity record to some gains new significance onstage. For those who loved the album, it still grows onstage, though someone like me who appreciates concerts for their visual spectacle may have felt a bit shortchanged by their lack-of-showiness. Crowd reaction was phenomenal for the first set overall, which means I'm probably just too stuck in my critic mindset!

The Second Set: Fun for all – sing-alongs, new tunes, “O Valencia”, “Engine Driver”, and possibly some Jersey love/hate… it started to drag after a while, mostly because a few songs were duds, judging by crowd reaction.

After over 2.5 hours the group finally finished up, so with their opener (the lovely Laura Viers and her Hall of Flames were a catchy bunch) the whole shindig ran 3.5 hours. And honestly, it was well worth it.



I left the Wellmont that night without much of an opinion - I think I was tired from a long show. As I started to realize exactly what transpired onstage that night, it started to grow on me. Sure, there were some glitches and cracks, but even if I disregarded their other plusses and just count the sonic benefits their live shows have over their recorded material, it was a worthwhile show. I’ll gladly see them again at first chance – just give me a little more legroom if I'm in the seats.


Lows:

-Not very visual at times - much like watching old-time radio actors do their performance. Because it was a sonic tale, the visual spectacle had some really big lulls
-As a result of the lulls in “Hazards”, awkward-feeling dances from the two guest performers felt painful
-“Alright, they’re finished playing… time to… no wait, there’s more? Okay… NOW they’re done… nope, wait! Oh, now they’re doing an encore? One song? No, two?” (Make up your mind, Decemberists! Don’t say “one more” when you mean at least a half dozen!)
-Wellmont balcony seats are not built for people who are six feet tall. Theories about the human race growing taller over time must be true.

Highs:

-For what it’s worth, their performance did have some great visual highs to match their sonic ones - The Queen, "The Rake's Song", and the vivid greens at the beginning and end.
-Chris Funk's pedal steel guitar - never had it jumped out at me on the album as much as it did onstage. It's beautiful.
-Colin Meloy’s playful relationship with the audience – from getting them singing, to telling them stories, to shouting down a guy who shouted up a silly request, he was not snooty as I had been previously led to believe. Nice suspenders too, dude.
-Seeing an age range from about 14 to 65 that included hippies, biker dudes, NPR nerds, college students and a guy that looked like he was from the new Where the Wild Things Are movie. ROCK!


Overall: 4/5 stars


(PS: I will do my best to air the Chris Funk interview this Sunday - I may have a live interview this week too, so it'll be a chock-full Campus Buzz! Tune in! 8-10 PM this Sunday!)

7.15.2009

Red Collar @ Pianos 7/14/09

Quick brief for everyone: Raggedy Annie and I made it out to Red Collar's show at Pianos last night. The show had a house of about 40 people, and despite a late start for the act their set was sizable and frankly quite outstanding. Their energy is outstanding, and their personality oozes out of their performance.


And the stage demeanor of Mike and Jason confirms what Jason said in our interview with him Sunday night - they are INCREDIBLY hard on their instruments. There was a mid-show guitar switch... not sure if it was because of broken strings, but most likely.


If you missed this show, you should be legitimately bummed out. Next time they're through NJ/NYC, get yourself there. Check their tour dates at www.redcollarmusic.com


(PS: Brief Style Alert: Cowboy boots with spurs = excellent choice. Good call, Jay.)

7.13.2009

REVIEW: Band of Skulls - Baby Darling Doll Face Honey

It becomes apparent from the opening riffs and vocals of Band of Skulls’ album “Baby Darling Doll Face Honey” (Shangri-La Records) that hyper-production and grand arrangement are not idols for the trio from Southampton, England. In fact, the grinding start of “The Light of the Morning” evokes an empty stage the day after a festival – the live-ins on the festival grounds are all still passed out in their tents, the light morning sun still unable to penetrate their eyelids after their final-night bender. A reveille of guitar and lo-fi voice fills their ears, reminding the masses that they actually have to drive their old Jeeps and Buick junkers back to another life they left behind mere days before. That’s the ambience that came through my speakers when I let BoS’s debut album play from beginning to end. This album sounds like the start of something – the start of a new day, the start of a road trip, the start of a band’s career – whatever that something is, it sounds pretty good.

After the rusty-Tin-Man start that is “Light of the Morning”, BoS marches into White Stripes territory with “Death by Diamonds and Pearls”, but quickly escapes the readymade comparisons with the soothing “Honest” and the groove-chic “Patterns”. In fact, these two songs, though buried in the middle of the album, are vital to hearing the sonic profile of Band of Skulls. The “hey” shouts in the cool-hot-cool-hot “Hollywood Ball” are some of the highest parts of the record. Plus, the soaring choruses of “Impossible” keep some of the other tracks on the back end of the album from sagging too low into Black Keys-esque fuzz-grunge noise.

The vocals of Russell Marsden and Emma Richardson are worth mentioning. Each of them alternates between soulful and ghostly, their harmonies are distinctive, and when they play off each other in rapid-fire fashion (like in the verses of “I Know What I Am”) the strength of Band of Skulls becomes apparent – as a drum-and-guitar trio, they do so much with so very little. Their music is fairly basic in structure, but “Baby Darling Doll Face Honey” seems to be the poster child for the idea of “Less is more”. It sounds roughly cut, and in the days of auto-tune, it’s almost a blessing to hear. I’m intrigued for their second album to see if their sound becomes more elaborate, or if it will maintain the simpler set-up that they established on their debut. Time will only tell, but for now, I’m going to put “Impossible” back on and enjoy heat of summer.

RATING: 3.5/5 stars

-Scarecrow

6.09.2009

Afterthoughts: Green Day - "21st Century Breakdown"

Now that the pre-release hype has died away, I've decided to take another look at Green Day's latest, 21st Century Breakdown.

Something about this album's sheer existence made it seem set up to fail. Billie Joe and crew had struck gold with American Idiot, somehow marrying multi-track thematics and ten-minute epics with their classic sound, making it one of the most successful albums of the 2000s. Beating that with their next album just seemed like a short-term form of Axl Rose syndrome - pre-release, review and post-release hype, the possibility of a stage production, movie, and more buzz surrounding American Idiot -- it all kept promo machine going through the massive gap of time between releases (nearly five years). Yet, fans and industry people still were left going "when is that next album ever going to come? And is it going to be remotely as good as Idiot?"

The release finally came about a month ago, and reviews have been mixed-to-positive. But that's not what I'm here to talk about. I want to focus on what the album is, and what it isn't.

First, what it is not:

A cement-strong concept album -- While their marketing message for the album plugged it as a three-act concept album, the threads of narrative and sound that stretch through this album are not very strong. Two main characters are spoken of (Gloria, Christian) but where they go and what they go through is vague. It's mostly presented as vignettes. No matter... it's enough to unify it, but it's not story heavy, like The Decemberists' recent The Hazards of Love

Classic Green Day - Strong affinity Dookie is nowhere to be found on this album. But on that note, affinity to Warning isn't here either. Of course, they haven't abandoned their core sound, but their song structures, production, epic key changes (see: chorus on "After the Lobotomy") seem to have sprung out of something new in the past five years. People looking for Green Day circa 1994 may be disappointed, but those who have decided that 15 years' worth of music and life experiences should yield some sonic change will notice a departure from the past. It's not like every song on this album is "Last Night on Earth" (whose closest similarity in the GD catalog is "Wake Me Up When September Ends"), but for every "East Jesus Nowhere" or that feels old school, there is a "Murder City" that toes the line between classic and new-sound, as well as a "Restless Heart Syndrome" straying way away from their core sound. It pretty much falls into perfect thirds - 6 tracks classic, 6 tracks new-sound, 6 tracks somewhere in between.

Heavy, deep, overwhelming social critique - Going off the concept-album idea, Green Day has consistently portrayed this as an even heavier look at what American society is like today. I see traces of it, and none of that is very poetic ("...the bastards of 1969!" doesn't roll off the tongue very well in the title track), but it DOES exist. But maybe that just does fit Green Day. They're not the kind of guys to hole up in the branches of trees to stop loggers, and they're definitely not a trio of Dylans, but they do get across the anxieties and idiosyncrasies they set out to portray.


What it IS:

Longer than I expected - This is satisfying to sit down and listen to all the way through because it actually has some length to it. For every 3-minute track there's a 5-minute beast (those are usually where the loose story plays through the most), and at 18 tracks that adds up. There's a few throwaway tracks like "Peacemaker" and "Know Your Enemy" (I have little doubt that long-term fan hindsight will put it into the lower tier of Green Day singles because it has this incredible ability to be catchy for the first minute and a half then mind-numbing for the rest)

Chock full of singles - when I heard "concept album" I got worried that there wouldn't be much radio-ready coming from 21st Century Breakdown. Hearing the repetitive "Know Your Enemy" made me even more worried - if this is the lead single, what will follow? After hearing the full album a few times, I remembered -- often the lead single isn't the best material off the album, even if it gets the most radio play. It happened with The Killers' Sam's Town ("Read My Mind" was the third single, but is probably one of the best songs the Killers have ever produced), It happened with U2's HtDaAB (The whole rest of the album was much better than "Vertigo")... and 21CB follows suit. I'm disappointed with the selection of "21 Guns" as the second single, but it's probably because it's being tied into the new Transformers movie soundtrack and needed to hit the airwaves sooner rather than later. Nevertheless, they have plenty of options for radio play all the way into the fall and even winter: "Viva La Gloria", "Last of the American Girls" and even the title track are excellent options.

Easy on the ears - Experimentation and sonic evolution don't always produce good results. (Case in point: U2's No Line on the Horizon, Metallica's St. Anger). While a few songs feel wonky ("Peacemaker") generally the stretching Green Day does is still accessible. You'll get what I mean when you hear the very beginning of "¿Viva La Gloria? (Little Girl)"... Question marks filled my head until the chorus came in, then it all felt right. That's a great microcosm that portrays the album in general -- the first time you hear it you may go "huh", but deep down listeners will find Green Day is still there.

Overall, I feel Green Day's latest is a fantastic work. American Idiot was hard to follow, but I think Green Day did it right - they didn't repeat that sound. I now think of Idiot as a stepping stone, bridging the sonic gap between Green Day's 90s work and 21st Century Breakdown. The album really isn't all they sold it to be (concept album, etc.) but what it truly IS doesn't come up short -- it's just different than what they said. Deep down, I just found the album to be satisfying, even on the first listen - something I can't usually say.

5.05.2009

REVIEW: Volbeat/Nightwish @ The Nokia 5/2/09

I went into the Nokia this past Saturday night hoping to confirm a few things.


1) I wanted to know if Volbeat, a new powerhouse of spins on WSOU, could support their new found success at WSOU with a good live show

2)if Nightwish could sound as good live as they do on their albums (since you can't fit a symphony orchestra onstage, I was a bit concerned).

3) if Anette Olzen could pull off old Nightwish tunes that Tarja so dominatingly wrote to showcase her operatic skills.

I think I came away from the show with relatively positive responses to all of those questions. This show rocked.



Volbeat opened with a really short set. Mike rocked a pompadour that was somewhere between Elvis and Morrissey (take your pick). Now I know where they got their epic Elvis-Skull-on-Wings logo. Mike was also very sick, and he made it known in his humorous breaks from playing. The band's personality really comes through onstage -- you can tell they have fun doing what they do. They dished on Amy Winehouse, they craftily deflected Slayer requests from the audience, and Mike even cheekily dished on Nightwish when he said "You don't f***ing cancel when you're in New York!", alluding to Nightwish's unfortunate cancellation last September due to Anette's loss of voice.

I think they only played 7-8 songs, but they included some of their biggest hits: "Radio Girl", "A Moment Forever", "Sad Man's Tongue", and "Mr. & Mrs. Ness". The devil horns quotient wasn't very high -- I think that people really haven't gotten full exposure to these guys. However, a few lighters (not phones) did pop up, and "Mr. & Mrs. Ness" got some jump action from the crowd.

Their groove and sometimes rockabilly sound is quite versatile. Honestly, I think they could open up for all sorts of acts until they get some more exposure, then they need to start headlining.



Moving onto Nightwish:

Their opening was awesome. Guest musician Troy Donockley played Sibelius' "Finlandia" on the Uilleann pipes in a bolero fashion as each band member came out one by one. Once they all got out, they drove straight into "7 Days to the Wolves", which was powerful, but felt a little rough. The band's stage presence was a little off. Annette's new look (Blonde hair, a dress that looked like an ill-fitting newspaper) and her stage moves (bad air guitar, lots of fist pumping into the air) just felt off. Whereas Tarja pretty much stood in place and let the band work around her, Anette is the polar opposite - she's prancing around stage, almost too much though. To add to the roughness of their stage presence, Marco and Erno seemed to have a hard time figuring out where to place themselves onstage, often scurrying back and forth and tapping each other on the shoulder telling them when they needed to move. It was as if half of their duo was consistently forgetting some sort of choreography they had planned on doing.

A few songs in, their stage presence evened out, and their music quality went up. "The Siren" showed Anette is more than capable of performing vocals written for the much more operatic Tarja. A few songs later, "Higher than Hope" further proved this. The song was dedicated to a friend of the band who died 6 years ago that day, and the performance was worthy of dedication - I think it was the best song of the night.

Of course, "The Poet and the Pendulum" was played, and it was serviceable, but there were higher points. Like I said, "Higher than Hope" was up there, but also the two-song set of "The Islander" and "Last of the Wilds" with Troy on the pipes again was a showstopper. I have not seen that many lighters in a venue, indoor or outdoor, in a long while. These two songs, when contrasted with "Romanticide", "Dead to the World" and their disco-metal-thump encore "I Wish I Had and Angel" show that this band is versatile in their sound, a lot of which can be chalked up to Tuomas, their principal songwriter.

The last song of their main set was "Dark Chest of Wonders", which answered my third question - Anette is worthy and capable of singing Tarja-geared vocals. They sound different, don't get me wrong. Anette is NOT an opera singer. But I think "Dark Chest..." is, oddly, Tarja's unexpected gift to her successor. Tarja always sounded like she was phoning it in on that song (album and live). Anette, who trended upward in enthusiasm and vocal quality as the show progressed, went out on a high note, singing it better than Tarja ever had. The song just seems more geared toward Anette than it ever was toward Tarja. A fantastic way to end the show.

While their overall sound is versatile, one thing jumped out at me during Nightwish's mid-set performance of "Nemo" - Anette started to improvise. I think her voice had gotten tired by then and she sang some parts as a sort of counter-harmony, and then at the end she broke down the melody into something new entirely. I realized that for most of their set that they hadn't done this yet. Now, some bands use the stage to mix up their tracks, while other play their tracks pretty much straight like the album cuts. Nightwish falls into the second category squarely. There's nothing wrong with that, because what's on the album is multi-layered and meaty to begin with. It's good to know that their sound translates perfectly to the stage, and maintains all of the energy it has on the record (example: my heart raced when Anette jumped back in after the mid-song instrumental breakdown of "7 Days...") But there wasn't a crazy, extended drum or guitar solo anywhere to be found in this show. It was quite straightforward, which was only slightly disappointing. Maybe I was hoping for too much and my bar was set too high though.

Nightwish set list:

Intro - Finlandia
7 Days to the Wolves
Dead to the World
The Siren
Amaranth
Romanticide
Higher than Hope
Poet and the Pendulum (complete)
Nemo
Sahara
The Islander
Last of the Wilds
Escapist
Dark Chest of Wonders

Encore: I Wish I Had an Angel


In conclusion, this was a fantastic two-band billing at a fantastic venue. I wasn't feeling very well that night so I sat in seats at the back. I took it all in while nursing a bad case of something-that-wasn't-Swine-Flu, yet I still felt like I was a part of the action where I was sitting. Volbeat got the crowd's blood pumping, and probably surprised everyone who hadn't heard of them before. Nightwish played a more-than-solid set overall, even after a rocky start. Both groups were very personable with the audience (Marco had some especially hilarious introductions to songs, including setting the scene for "Romanticide" by making the audience picture a farting husband and his unshaven wife) and just generally seemed like they wanted to be there.

So, to loop back and answer my three starting points:

1) Volbeat can hold their own onstage. They could probably have done even better if Mike wasn't sick.

2) Nightwish sounds great live. The whole group appeared to need a song or two to get into form (both physically and musically) but once they were on-point they were fantastic.

3) Anette's vocals were solid overall and she sang the old Nightwish material just as well as the new. Her vocals outclasses her goofy stage presence.

-----

HIGHS: Both acts were great with audience, "A Moment Forever", "Mr. & Mrs. Ness", "Higher than Hope" (and the accompanying sea of about 5 dozen lighters), watching Tuomas drain about 2/3 of a 30 oz mid-song, a show that actually started on time for a change.

LOWS: Volbeat's less-than-40-minute set, Anette's wardrobe (what was she wearing?), "Sahara" was weak.

ONE WORD: Energetic.

3.24.2009

REVIEWED: The Decemberists' "Hazards of Love"

When the The Decemberists got into the writing process for their new album, Capitol Records must have known they had struck musical gold again with the band. Why else would their management, promoters and label have encouraged the recording and upcoming release this 17-track, 59 minute long, meandering epic entitled The Hazards of Love? Especially since there was a two and a half year gap since their last album, The Crane Wife, one might not expect Capitol records to take such a risk unless the material was good. Even the title alone, which is shared by four of its tracks, screams this word of caution to any record executive with business sense. In today’s iTunes world, the radio single may not be as important, but the individual track is even more important, so when a band asks its listeners to listen to a seventeen-track concept album with several principle characters to follow, the order is a pretty tall one. For anyone able to stop sending updates to their twitter long enough to sit down for an hour and listen to through the new Decemberists album, they will find that the band delivers, and while it may not have been their goal to prove prog rock can still be relevant in the 21st st century, they might have done that too.

This album was meant to be listened to from front to back. It’s got an overture and a sort of epilogue track that sits alone after the grand finale of the album, and the interior of the album’s track lineup is structured almost like a symphony, with movements and reprisals and contrasting voices. The Decemberists have always developed complex arrangements in their music, but they’ve stretched their sound to include some grungy, bluesy sounds that introduce the Queen in the story, a creepy zombie-child chorus, and even some sludgy metal riffs to top it all off.

The album isn’t flawless. It is a little slow to get moving, and there's one track I consistently cringe while listening through ("Isn't it a Lovely Night") The album introduces a bunch of characters to a narrative that can be understood if you listen hard and maybe cheat by looking at the lyrics, but might not have the accessibility that their previous work had in terms of storytelling content. That’s kind of ironic, considering the Decemberists are known for their storytelling capabilities, and this is their biggest endeavor yet. If the Decemberist were looking to have their cake and eat it to by writing a mega concept album and craft a Billboard chart single, they didn’t manage it. Their last album had "O Valencia" but this album’s best candidate is probably the song "Hazards of Love 2 (Wager All)", which still is not exactly named for radio consumption. So, let us just assume that Decemberists are trying to make it big, just not the traditional ways of the music industry. No fault of theirs, just... different.

Aside from the album's shortcomings, there's lots to love here. I found myself humming at least a half-dozen different melodies from HoL, tapped a few of its percussion breaks on my knee and otherwise found myself defaulting to it on my computer whenever I needed music. "The Wanting Comes In Waves/Repaid" is probably one of the highest points on the records, as Colin Meloy's leading man debates with the Queen of the forest, harpsichords and bluesy guitar dueling all the way, and a soaring chorus to complement it all. "The Rake's Song" is decidedly creepy and percussion heavy, but "Hazards of Love 3 (Revenge!)" beats it out for the creepy factor. While themes are repeated across the album, the content never feels stagnant, much to the credit of The Decemberists.

In the end, there’s little question about it – The Decemberists will floor their devoted fans with the content on this album. It's an infecting, well-produced piece of music; There's no denying that. Whether it will get extensive crossover appeal is hard to say because this album is not very easily subdivided into single tracks for someone to grab off of iTunes. Maybe they’re trying to make a statement to the mainstream by doing this, or maybe they just got a great idea and went with it. Either way, this album can’t be judged by the number of copies it may or may not sell, because if it tanks, that’s just too bad. This album is an experience, and a pretty darn good one at that. If you have an hour to kick around, give Hazards of Love a listenthrough in one sitting. Do it again a second time, and you’ll pick up more nuance. That’s music appreciation at its best, and Hazards of Love delivers on that front. It’s not Top 40, nor is it extreme – it’s Decemberists doing what they know how to do, and doing it to epic proportions. It’s got a few flaws, but it’s the best thing I’ve heard so far in 2009.

I give it a 9 out of 10.

3.02.2009

U2 Miscellany

Here's some No Line On The Horizon miscellany:

CNN's Denise Quan interviewed the band ahead of tomorrow's album release. Turns out they were legitimately trying not to sound like typical U2.

As for Austin360.com, Joe Gross has suggested in his review that you reprogram the album's tracks into a different order (while dropping a few) for maximum enjoyment. I tried it, and he's on to something -- the album could use a bit of a rearrangement..

[His order: 4-3-2-1-7-8-9-11]

2.25.2009

U2's No Line On The Horizon - Review

U2 has always been able to walk the thin line between reinvention and repetition in their long history. It's been said again and again, but a band capable of staying relevant for 30 years has something good, some sort of secret X-factor that allows them to do that. If you look back at their history, rarely can you say that two of their albums have sounded the same. All that You Can't Leave Behind is NOT Pop is NOT Achtung Baby is NOT Joshua Tree is... well, you get what I mean.

This time around, U2 yet has modified their tone again to create a cohesive, listenable-from-front-to-back album, all while managing to keep their core sound intact. It becomes obvious why this album was given a March release date and not a bombastic June blowout -- U2 comes off as much more reflective this time around then even their last record, How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb. Like the album cover, there's a certain sense of zen and calm on these eleven tracks that is unlike anything I've heard from the group before. In fact, it's probably good to note that the lead single, "Get On Your Boots" is not a good representative of the content of the rest of the album -- that song's a standalone, as if the band was lobbying to be the theme song of the next Bond movie.

The album starts off strong. "No Line on the Horizon" has two heads - Bono lets lose on the verses, but the chorus is reeled in a sort of good-cop-bad-cop routine that is surprisingly effective. It gives way to "Magnificent", a slow-building synthfest that gives way to some classic Edge work and a Bono preoccupation with the title word. It remotely feels like "Original of the Species, Part Two". "The Moment of Surrender" is one of the high points of the album -- Bono might have finally Found What He Was Looking For.

Other points of note on the album include the three-song sequence of "Stand Up Comedy", the confusingly-named "FEZ - Being Born" and "White As Snow". The three tracks almost run as a three-moment piece, because the transitions between these varied tracks are virtually seamless. "White As Snow" is bound to become a fan favorite, but "FEZ" stands highest among the three - it calls back to "The Unforgettable Fire" or "Acrobat" in its arena grandeur. A final high point worth noting is the second-to-last track, the 5-minute long "Breathe", where Edge and Bono seemed to show a little Bob Dylan influence.


Now, that X-factor I mentioned? It becomes quite apparent on this album that their secret weapon has been and still is long-time producer Brian Eno. Some cracks are apparent in the facade of this U2 installment ("Unknown Caller" relies heavily on the band's chanting segments of the lyrics, which sounds less like a motif than a lack of inspiration for a tune) but Eno has done a great job of giving this batch of tracks integrity, and even a subtle unity. It makes sense that the one sore thumb ("Get On Your Boots") is a Steve Lillywhite production and not Eno's. Otherwise, the album is a masterpiece of production. Clicks, whirs, synth and vague echoes to previous tracks all seem to fit together like a dream that slips away when you wake up.

The album stumbles a bit at the end -- Bono starts to ramble on "Cedars of Lebanon", as if Sting and Randy Newman had a lovechild whose future career narrating documentaries. But whether or not one finds it to be an overwhelming problem relies on their philosophy about music listening. For those in the 21st century who do not listen to albums from beginning to end anymore (read: virtually everyone) there is lots here to pick and choose from. For those who do listen through albums in their entirety, it does not really detract from the overall package.

No Line on the Horizon mostly imparts a feeling of reflection. The members of U2 are getting older -- they have been from the day they released "Boy". Their trip through life has produced everything from "Sunday Bloody Sunday" to "With Or Without You" to "The Fly" to "Vertigo". One can get the feeling from No Line that these guys are taking a breather to reflect on everything that has come before. We got hints of this on How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb ("Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own"), but it's full-force on this album. Introspection is fine, as long as it doesn't overtake you.

This is not a bad album. In fact it is a nice addition to U2's body of work, expanding into some aural territories they have not touched much on before. It's understated, and maybe it's understated to a fault. With that established, this thought lingers: the next album needs to be fierce.

Scarecrow's Score: 6/10

2.23.2009

LIVEBLOGGING U2's "NO LINE ON THE HORIZON"

Let's try this out... Just got U2's album in today here @ WSOU, and I'm going to liveblog my listening of U2's new album, "No Line on the Horizon" right now. An in-depth review to follow, but here's first impressions:

Track 1 - No Line on the Horizon - Great intro. It feels very ballsy for U2 in a counterintuitive kind of way. It's kind of retro. Bono's yelping in the verses, and I like it. "I know a girl..." starts out the verses in a very retroish way. Digging it.

Track 2 - Magnificent - Grungy start, Bass drum heavy. Some synth(?) syncopation. Very "late night on a big city street after the rain" feel. Like a danceable Taxi Driver. Once the intro gives way to the lyrics, it's not booming, but it's catchy. Does feel... old. These guys are aging, this album hasn't hidden that yet. But they're aging gracefully so far on this album.

Track 3 - Moment of Surrender - I liked this song a lot that I didn't even type much. I just kind of listened. The title lyrics pop out at you. It's engrossing.

Track 4 - Unknown Caller - Starts out like a rainstorm. Then, Bono's falsetto is iffy. The Edge backs it up with a beautiful riff or three that sounds like he made it up as he went (in a good way). Lyrics don't hit till about 1:50 in, which doesn't feel like it because you get lost in Edge's guitar. This sounds like something that could have been on All You Can't Leave Behind. The chorus is kind of flat. It's chanted, not sung. The title makes me think of "The Fly" (which is a call from a resident of Hell, according to the band), but this isn't Achtung Baby at all. It's more "Walk On" than anything. Not my favorite track so far, but I think it might be a third or fourth-single. Take close note at the Edge's guitar solo... this might have been what they meant when talking about this being "different" or "experimental". The Edge's solos are usually tight and short. Wow, I had lots to say in these 6 minutes... next track.

Track 5 - I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight - What an unfortunate title. Starts strong, Bono's falsetto bugs me a bit (it doesn't fit). Lyrics are substantial, sounds like Atomic Bomb, but not. What amazes me again and again about U2 is their ability to change their sound album after album - except for their first few albums, you can't say that one sounds like the next (Achtung Baby is NOT Joshua Tree is NOT Pop is NOT Atomic Bomb is NOT this.) At about 2:30, I hear some ugly synth I think. U2 rarely does well when they go outside of their standard instrumentation. Or wait, might those be real cellos?

Track 6 - Get On Your Boots - I think I'm listening to the Strokes after that intro. Wait. This is the single. The video underscores what I said from the first time I heard it: It's U2's attempt at making a theme song for a Bond film. Does anyone realize how little Bono actually sings in this song after the first 50 seconds? The rest is mostly chorus and breakdown... I think the best way to describe this is "Love it, Hate it". I happen to kind of like it. It's growing on me.

Track 7 - Stand Up Comedy - U2-tries-funk. A few seconds in I think he made a Twin Towers reference. If I'm right... Oh Bono. Anyways, It's got a groove to it. The falsetto here's not bad. One thing I am noticing... The songs don't necessarily sound the same, but they aren't incredibly varied. I think that's true of a lot of their albums. No album sounds the same as another, but what's on there is produced in such a way that the album is unified in a certain tone. (This is Eno coming through).

Track 8 - Fez (Being Born) - Echoes of "Get on Your Boots" are layered over a very smooth, slightly creepy intro. 1 minute in it gets crazy, then the song picks up in a way that I haven't seen since the long intro of "The Unforgettable Fire". Started out odd, but it's slowly becoming one of my favorite songs in this listen-through so far.

Track 9 - White As Snow - More of this electronic-techni-production that sounds like it could be a Radiohead B-side, but again, it gives way about a minute in to something different. A ballad. "All I Have Is You" or "One Step Closer" come to mind. It'll take a few more listens from the world, but this might become a U2 classic. Not like the rest of the album in arrangement. A little bluesy-folksy.

Track 10 - Breathe - Another bubbling, searing, seething intro. Sounds positively angry. It's almost like a hi-fi Black Keys intro. Now it's getting into a bluesy guitar jam. Bono ran out of notes, so he just reads the lyrics. Waiting for "Bad to the Bone" to come on... well it was just a joke, but anyways, that part gave way to a chorus. Beautiful actually. The Edge shines here. And the chords and arrangements are not what you'd expect.

Track 11 - Cedars of Lebanon - the big finish... or is it? Bono's sitting in a bar or coffee house somewhere, and he's missing something. It is rambling but kind of relaxing. Not sure how I feel. Wait for the final review.


----

That's it for now. You can stream it from their myspace if you want to play along. Comment with thoughts when you listen to it, or just comment on my own ramblings.

12.22.2008

Matisyahu reviewed!

December 23, 2008

Hanukkah Receives Kosher Pop Welcome

Matisyahu deployed what may be the only large, mirrored, rotating dreidel in show business — a Jewish answer to a disco ball — at Webster Hall on Sunday night, the first night of Hanukkah. It was also the first of eight New York City shows for Matisyahu in his third annual Festival of Lights series, bringing different opening acts and guests each night. A large menorah was set up for a mid-concert lighting ceremony, with the blessings declaimed in Hebrew by an audience volunteer.

Matisyahu, who was born Matthew Miller, sings explicitly devotional songs about God, Moshiach (the Messiah) and Orthodox Jewish identity. By setting them to reggae, rock and hip-hop beats, and after working his way up the jam-band circuit, he also reaches listeners with their minds on more secular pursuits, like dancing and drugs. Simcha Levenberg, the M.C. who introduced him, drew big laughs with jokes about marijuana and LSD, although Matisyahu’s song “King Without a Crown” insisted, “If you’re trying to stay high, then you’re bound to be low.”

Matisyahu has built a career on analogies between Rastafarian roots reggae and Hasidic songs. Both are concerned with faith and survival struggles and have lyrics phrased in Biblical allusions; both draw on modal scales and melismatic vocal lines that can sound Middle Eastern. Near the end of the concert Matisyahu sang long, cantorial phrases while rocking back and forth, as if davening, or praying. Yet if his lyrics weren’t so clear about their references to Jewish history and the majesty of God, most of the time Matisyahu would simply be one more reggae-loving rocker.

In “Jerusalem,” which drew heartfelt singalongs, he worries about assimilation, singing, “Cut off the roots of your family tree/Don’t you know that’s not the way to be.” But the roots of his music are Afro-Caribbean and African-American. He uses Jamaican reggae and dancehall toasting, sometimes delivered with a Jamaican accent; he also uses hip-hop cadences and showed off his vocal beatboxing.

His band also segues into rock, for chiming marches that borrow their idealistic sound from U2. Matisyahu is less concerned with a musical heritage than with a religious one.

Album by album Matisyahu has expanded his music. Along with basic roots reggae he now uses faster, tongue-twisting dancehall toasting and the electronic beats and brooding chords of hip-hop. And he’s looking farther: Matisyahu joined Crystal Method, the thumping, rock-tinged electronica duo that opened the show, to sing and rap on a song from their next album, due in March.

Matisyahu rarely improves on his sources. His voice is thin and sometimes nasal, closer to Jack Johnson than to Bob Marley or Sting; his rhymes can be as awkward as they are earnest. But his band — which was augmented, for a few songs, by an Israeli oud player — carries simple vamps through multiple transformations, from meditations to shredding guitar solos. It’s music for believers, with a groove for everyone else.

Matisyahu is at Webster Hall, 125 East 11th Street, East Village, Tuesday and Thursday , and at the Music Hall of Williamsburg, 66 North Sixth Street, at Wythe Avenue, Saturday through Dec. 30. Tickets: (212) 307-7171 or ticketmaster.com.

10.16.2008

Keane's Perfect Symmetry REVIEWED

Keane desperately wants synth to be back in style. If Perfect Symmetry has any defining characteristic, it is the whirs and screeches and chords that can make anyone want to jump into a Duran Duran or Phil Collins video. But the question that arises when listening through the album is whether or not retro pop-rock is a progression or if it’s just old news.

At first listen, this album seems like a deviation from Keane’s first two major releases. This album mostly lacks the smooth charm of Hopes and Fears and throws out the dissonant tension of Under the Iron Sea. However, a few songs scream “classic Keane” on this album. After the first chorus of “The Lovers are Losing” you’ll be remembering the first few times you listened through “Can’t Stop Now” or “Leaving So Soon”. This is not meant to imply that Keane keeps writing the same songs. Like I said earlier, Perfect Symmetry is definitely different from the first two albums. However Tom Chaplin and company got into this new retro groove is outside my knowledge. Were they sitting around listening to Invisible Touch and got some ideas, or did they try something out and it just happened to gel… who knows? In the end, after a few listens, the initial thought stands: this material is a deviation from “classic” Keane. Despite a few oddities, like the vaguely creepy synth track on “Better Than This”, the sound is good.

As for the content of the album, there are several apparent singles, but no filler material is apparent. The album is fairly consistent all the way through. A few high points are worth noting though. The chorus of “The Lovers Are Losing” carries the song’s weight; it’s long, wordy and worthy of a grand sing-along. “You Haven’t Told Me Anything” is begging for a DJ to remix it, with its syncopated beats. And “Playing Along” seems to have some guitarish charms, something that’s rare for Keane.

So, is retro pop-rock an artistic progression, or is it just recycled motifs? The jury’s still out, but Keane HAS managed to take retro styling and apply it to the Keane sound to create something new entirely. Three albums into Keane’s major label career, I can only name a few groups who have truly reinvented their sound for each of their first three albums – U2 and Coldplay. So, maybe the comparisons go beyond just Keane’s sound, down to their actual composing qualities. Keane has put out another great album that should dispel uneasiness that might have arisen from Iron Sea’s sophomore slump. It’s catchy, it’s quality, and is destined to be a notable entry in the Keane catalog.